How Odhi Reads Research: What We Cite, and What We Don’t Claim

Odhi, a capybara, standing up to look at something with Pip the bird nearby
Odhi, a capybara, standing up to look at something with Pip the bird nearby

Health apps love a citation. A small superscript number, a journal name, and suddenly a rough guess feels settled. I didn't want Odhi to do that. So when I wrote its research pages, I set myself a stricter rule than I expected to need.

Three piles

Everything I found went into one of three piles.

Read in full. I read the whole paper. Only these are cited as support.

See also, summary only. I know the paper from its abstract or a summary. I list it so you can go and read it yourself, but I quote no figures from it, because I can't vouch for them.

Left out. Anything I couldn't check at all, or whose reference I couldn't confirm. These don't appear.

When I sorted what I had, the result was humbling. Only three papers made the first pile, and for two of Odhi's features, none did.

What that looks like in practice

For the optional snoring feature, the two papers I've read in full are about wearables worn by people being assessed for sleep apnoea, not about a phone listening to a room. They report how well a wrist or finger device agreed with a sleep test. They're useful for a small supporting signal and for a reminder of how much results depend on who was studied. They say nothing about whether a phone on a bedside table can do the same job, so the page says that plainly.

For the migraine heads-up, I have read none of the related papers in full. The page says "Cited as support: none", lists the papers I know as summary only, and notes that results in this area look modest and uneven. That's why the feature shows itself only when a test on your own history beats two naive guesses, and why many people will never see it.

For the fitness estimate, I read the paper behind a published model. Then I found I couldn't verify the equations from a secondary summary, so Odhi holds none of them. The feature is blocked until someone transcribes the equations from the paper and checks them.

For the everyday insights, no clinical paper is relied on at all. They use ordinary statistics on your own data.

Marking every threshold

A second habit: every number in the open method is labelled as cited, summary only, a design value, or a heuristic. A heuristic is a rule of thumb I chose, with no study behind it. There are many of those, and I'd rather you see them than assume they were borrowed from somewhere official.

Not claiming too much

Odhi's experimental features carry one status line everywhere they appear: observations only, not a diagnosis, not clinically validated against sleep studies, experimental. I mean each part of it. They have been tried on made-up data and in internal tests. They haven't been run against real sleep-study or migraine data.

I'm one person, not a research group. If you work in a university, hospital or sleep lab and want to test, challenge or improve any of this, the open method page has an outline for testing it properly and a way to reach me. I'd rather be shown a flaw than keep one.